Proxy Islamicity Index

Tulisan ini berisi daftar proxy yang dipakai untuk mengukur Islamicity Index dari paper "An Economic Islamicity Index". Komentar tentang paper ini menyusul, sekarang melakukan dulu cross check data yang dipakai pada paper tersebut.

Tabel di bawah ini sumbernya adalah dari Appendix di Global Economy Journal: An Economic Islamicity Index (EI2)

Tulisan ini sumber primernya adalah 2 paper berikut ini:Sumber Paper
- How Islamic are Islamic Countries?
- An Economic Islamicity Index , papernya  juga dapat diambil di  URL: http://relooney.fatcow.com/0_NS4053_1106.pdf

 

SUMMARY OF ISLAMIC ECONOMIC CATEGORIES, SUB-CATEGORIES AND THEIR PROXY VARIABLES

Dimension ECONOMIC PRINCIPLES SUBCATEGORY PROXY
A ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY AND ECONOMIC FREEDOM
   

A. Gender Equality Indicators (sepertinya diambil dari http://hdr.undp.org/en/statistics/gii/ )

 

Proxy 1: United Nations Human Development Index Of Female Economic Activity Rate (% Ages 15 And Older)
Proxy 2: United Nations Human Development Index Of Gender Empowerment Measure (GEM) Rank
   

B. Other Non-discriminatory Indicators

(mustinya ada di http://hdr.undp.org/en/statistics/hdi/ , tapi tidak ketemu link pastinya)

Proxy 3: United Nations Human Development Index Of International Convention On The Elimination Of All Forms Of Racial Discrimination
Proxy 4: United Nations Human Development Index Of The International Covenant On Economic, Social And Cultural Rights
    C. Labor Market Indicators (data dari bagian ini semua diambil dari Fraser Institute) Proxy 5: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Impact Of Minimum Wage [PDF]
Proxy 6: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Hiring And Firing Practices [PDF]
Proxy 7: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Share Of Labor Force Whose Wages Are Set By Centralized Collective Bargaining [PDF]
Proxy 8: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Unemployment Benefits [PDF]
Proxy 9: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Labor Freedom [PDF]
   

D. Ease of Doing Business Indicators

( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_Doing_Business_Index )

Proxy 10: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Starting A Business http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 11: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Dealing With Licenses (yang ada dealing with construction permits) http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 12: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Employing Workers
Proxy 13: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Registering Property http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 14: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Getting Credit http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 15: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Protecting Investors Paying Taxes http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 16: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Trading Across Borders http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings

Proxy 17: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Enforcing Contracts http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings
Proxy 18: World Bank Ease Of Doing Business Ranking Of Closing A Business (yang ada resolving insolvency http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings)

   

E. Economic Freedom Indicators

(data dari bagian sepertinya diambil dari Fraser Institute namun di laporan 2011 ada beberapa bagian yang tidak ada)

Proxy 19: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Price Controls (ada di laporan 2011)
Proxy 20: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Burden Of Regulation (tidak ada di laporan 2011)
Proxy 21: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Time With Government Bureaucracy (di report 2011 parameter ini tidak ada)
Proxy 22: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Starting A New Business (ada di laporan 2011)
Proxy 23: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Irregular Payments (tidak ada di laporan 2011)

   

F. Business and Market Freedom Indicator

Tentang Heritage Foundation Index: Thttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom

Fraser Institute

Proxy 24: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Business Freedom (ada)
Proxy 25: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Monetary Freedom (ada)
Proxy 26: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Protection Of Intellectual Property (tidak ketemu di laporan Fraser Institute 2011)
B JUSTICE IN ALL ASPECTS OF ECONOMIC MANAGEMENT I.E. PROPERTY RIGHTS AND THE SANCTITY OF CONTRACTS
    A. Property and Contract Rights Proxy 27: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Property Rights ( http://www.heritage.org/index/property-rights )
C BETTER TREATMENT OF WORKERS INCLUDING JOB CREATION AND EQUAL ACCESS TO EMPLOYMENT
    A. Equal employment and Job Creation
Proxy 28: World Bank Development Indicators Of Unemployment, Total (% Of Total Labor Force) ( http://data.worldbank.org/indicator )
Proxy 29: World Bank Development Indicators Of Labor Force, Female (% Of Total Labor Force) ( http://data.worldbank.org/indicator )
D HIGHER EDUCATION EXPENDITURES RELATIVE TO GDP INCLUDING EQUAL ACCESS TO EDUCATION
    A. Education Index Indicator Proxy 30: United Nations Human Development Index Of Education Index ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_Index )
    B. Education Public Expenditures Indicator Proxy 31: United Nations Human Development Index Of Public Expenditure On Education (% Of GDP) (sepertinya dari http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SE.XPD.TOTL.GB.ZS , tapi ini tidak lengkap)
Proxy 32: United Nations Human Development Index Of Public Expenditure On Education (As % Of Total Government Expenditure) ( http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/indicators/default.html -> http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/indicators/38006.html )
    C. Education Equality Indicator Proxy 33: World Bank Development Indicators Of Ratio Of Girls To Boys In Primary And Secondary Education (%)
    D. Education Effectiveness Indicator
Proxy 34: World Bank Development Indicators Of Literacy Rate, Adult Total (% Of People Ages 15 And Above)
E POVERTY ERADICATION, AID, AND PROVIDING BASIC HUMAN NEEDS, NO HOARDING OF WEALTH I.E. ECONOMIC EQUITY, AND LESS OPULENCE IN
CONSUMPTION
 
A. Poverty Effectiveness Indicator
Proxy 35: World Bank Development Indicators Of Malnutrition Prevalence, Height For Age (% Of Children Under 5) + World Bank
Development Indicators Of Malnutrition Prevalence, Weight For Age (% Of Children Under 5)
Proxy 36: United Nations Human Development Index Of Life Expectancy At Birth (Years)
    B. Provision of Healthcare Indicators

Proxy 37: United Nations Human Development Index Of Health Expenditure Per Capita (PPP US$)
Proxy 38: United Nations Human Development Index Of Physicians
(Per 100,000 People) + World Bank Development Indicators Of Physicians (Per 100,000 People)
Proxy 39: United Nations Human Development Index Of Public Expenditure On Health (% Of GDP)
Proxy 40: United Nations Human Development Index Of Public Health Expenditure (% Of GDP)
Proxy 41: United Nations Human Development Index Of Tuberculosis Cases - Prevalence (Per 100,000 People)
Proxy 42: World Bank Development Indicators Of Health Expenditure Per Capita (Current US$)
Proxy 43: World Bank Development Indicators Of Health Expenditure, Private (% Of GDP)
Proxy 44: World Bank Development Indicators Of Health Expenditure, Public (% Of GDP)
Proxy 45: World Bank Development Indicators Of Health Expenditure, Total (% Of GDP)
    C. Alms/Charity Indicator Proxy 46: World Bank Development Indicators Of Aid (% Of Central Government Expenditures)
F A MORE EVEN DISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH AND INCOME
      N/A No Reliable Proxy Available
G BETTER SOCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND PROVISION OF SOCIAL SERVICES THROUGH TAXATION AND SOCIAL WELFARE
    A. Fiscal Freedom Indicator Proxy 47: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Fiscal Freedom
 
    B. Tax Level Indicator

Proxy 48: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Top Marginal Income Tax Rate (And Income Threshold At Which It
Applies)

Proxy 49: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Top Marginal Income And Payroll Tax Rate (And Income Threshold At Which The Top Marginal Income-Tax Rate Applies)
Proxy 50: World Bank Development Indicators Of Highest Marginal Tax Rate, Corporate Rate (%)
Proxy 51: World Bank Development Indicators Of Highest Marginal Tax Rate, Individual (On Income Exceeding, US$)
Proxy 52: World Bank Development Indicators Of Highest Marginal Tax Rate, Individual Rate (%)
Proxy 53: World Bank Development Indicators Of Other Taxes (% Of Revenue)
Proxy 54: World Bank Development Indicators Of Taxes On Income, Profits And Capital Gains (% Of Revenue)
Proxy 55: World Bank Development Indicators Of Taxes On Income, Profits And Capital Gains (% Of Total Taxes)
Proxy 56: World Bank Development Indicators Of Total Tax Payable By Businesses (% Of Gross Profit)

    C. Taxation Level Indicator
Proxy 57: World Bank Development Indicators Of Tax Revenue (% Of GDP) + World Bank Development Indicators Of Gross National Expenditure (% Of GDP)
    D. Freedom From Government Indicator

Proxy 58: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Freedom From Government
H HIGHER SAVINGS AND INVESTMENT RATES I.E. MANAGEMENT OF NATURAL AND DEPLETABLE RESOURCES
A. Quality of Economic Spending

Proxy 59: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of General Government Consumption Spending As A % Of Total Consumption

Proxy 60: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Government Enterprises And Investment As A % Of Total Investment

Proxy 61: World Bank Development Indicators Of Adjusted Savings: Energy Depletion (% Of GNI)
Proxy 62: World Bank Development Indicators Of Private Investment In Energy (Current US$)
Proxy 63: World Bank Development Indicators Of Private Investment In Telecoms (Current US$)
Proxy 64: World Bank Development Indicators Of Private Investment In Transport (Current US$)
Proxy 65: World Bank Development Indicators Of Private Investment In Water And Sanitation (Current US$)
Proxy 66: World Bank Development Indicators Of Subsidies And Other Transfers (% Of Expense)
Proxy 67: World Bank Development Indicators Of Transfers And Subsidies As A % Of GDP
Proxy 68: World Bank Development Indicators Of Subsidies And Other Transfers (Current LCU)

    B. Savings Indicator Proxy 69: World Bank Development Indicators Of Adjusted Savings: Net National Savings (% Of GNI)
I HIGHER MORAL STANDARD, HONESTY AND TRUST EXHIBITED IN THE MARKETPLACE AND IN ALL ECONOMIC INTERACTIONS I.E. LESS CORRUPTION
    A. Transparency International Indicator Proxy 70: Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI)
    B. Freedom from Corruption Indicator Proxy 71: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Freedom From Corruption
J ISLAMIC FINANCIAL SYSTEM I: NO EXPLOITIVE SPECULATION AND RISK SHARING AS OPPOSED TO DEBT CONTRACTS I.E. A SUPPORTIVE
FINANCIAL SYSTEM
    A. Investment Freedom + Financial Freedom Proxy 72: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Investment Freedom Index
Proxy 73: The Heritage Foundation Index Of Economic Freedom Of Financial Freedom Index
    B. Banking Sector Indicator

Proxy 74: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Freedom To Own Foreign Currency Bank Accounts Domestically And Abroad


Proxy 75: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Difference Between Official Exchange Rate And Black-Market Rate
Proxy 76: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Foreign Ownership/Investment Restrictions
Proxy 77: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Restrictions On Proxy 78: The Freedom Of Citizens To Engage In Capital Market Exchange With Foreigners
Proxy 79: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Ownership of banks
Proxy 80: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Competition
Proxy 81: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Extension of credit
Proxy 82: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Interest Rate Controls/Negative Real Interest Rates
Proxy 83: World Bank Development Indicators Of Financial Information Infrastructure Index
Proxy 84: World Bank Development Indicators Recurring Earning Power, %
Proxy 85: World Bank Development Indicators Of Bank Capital To Assets (%)

    C. Financial Market Risk Indicator
Proxy 86: The PRS Group International Country Risk Guide (ICRG) of Country Financial Market Risk Index
    D. Investment, Portfolio, & Capital Flows Indicator

Proxy 87: World Bank Development Indicators Of Domestic Credit To Private Sector (% Of GDP)
Proxy 88: World Bank Development Indicators Of Foreign Direct Investment, Net Inflows (% Of GDP)
Proxy 89: World Bank Development Indicators Of Foreign Direct Investment, Net Outflows (% Of GDP)
Proxy 90: World Bank Development Indicators Of Gross Private Capital Flows (% Of GDP)
Proxy 91: World Bank Development Indicators Of Portfolio Investment, Excluding LCFAR (BOP, Current US$)
Proxy 92: World Bank Development Indicators Of Portfolio Investment, Bonds (PPG + PNG) (NFL, Current US$)
Proxy 93: World Bank Development Indicators Of Portfolio investment, Equity (DRS, Current US$)
Proxy 94: World Bank Development Indicators Of Stocks Traded, Total Value (% Of GDP)
K ISLAMIC FINANCIAL SYSTEM II: FINANCIAL PRACTICES THAT INCLUDES THE ABOLITION OF INTEREST
    A. Absence of Interest Indicator Proxy 95: Bankscope Data On Non-Interest Income/Assets, (% )
L HIGHER TRADE/GDP, HIGHER FOREIGN AID/GDP AND HIGHER DEGREE OF ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVATION AND VIGILANTLY SUPERVISED MARKETS I.E. OVERALL STATE EFFECTIVENESS IN ACHIEVING ECONOMIC PROSPERITY -- GENERAL ECONOMIC PROSPERITY
    A. Macro Economic Indicator

Proxy 96: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Money Growth

Proxy 97: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Standard Deviation Of Inflation
Proxy 98: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Inflation Rate (Most Recent Year)
Proxy 99: World Bank Development Indicators Of Total Debt Service (% Of Exports Of Goods, Services And Income)
Proxy 100: World Bank Development Indicators Of Multilateral Debt Service (% Of Public And Publicly Guaranteed Debt Service)
Proxy 101: World Bank Development Indicators Of Long-Term Debt (DOD, Current US$)

    B. Economic Development Success Indicator Proxy 102: United Nations Human Development Index (HDI)
    C. Degree of Globalization& Trade Indicator Proxy 103: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Taxes On International Trade
Proxy 104: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Mean Tariff Rate
Proxy 105: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Standard Deviation Of Tariff Rates
Proxy 106: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Non-Tariff Trade Barriers
Proxy 107: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Compliance cost of importing and exporting
Proxy 108: Fraser Institute Economic Freedom Of The World Index Of Size Of The Trade Sector Relative To Expected
Proxy 109: World Bank Development Indicators Of Patent Applications, Nonresidents
Proxy 110: World Bank Development Indicators Of Patent Applications, Residents
Proxy 111: World Bank Development Indicators Of Taxes On International Trade (% Of Revenue)
    D. General Prosperity Indicator

Proxy 112: World Bank Development Indicators Of GDP (PPP) Growth (Annual %) From 1994-2005

Proxy 113: GDP Per Capita PPP (In $)


























Comments

Respon terhadap paper

Respon terhadap paper tersebut di berbagai media dan blog:
- Negara Barat yang Islami http://sosbud.kompasiana.com/2011/11/05/negara-barat-yang-islami/
- Hasil Penelitian: Keislaman Indonesia Kalah Ketimbang Negara Lain - Hasil Penelitian Keislaman Indonesia kalah ketimbang negara lain http://www.kbr68h.com/berita/nasional/14858-hasil-penelitian-keislaman-i...
- Insight: How Islamic are Islamic countries? A rejoinder http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2011/11/12/insight-how-islamic-are-is...
Respon terhadap paper tersebut di berbagai blog:
- http://suamigila.com/2011/11/10/how-islamic-are-islamic-countries/
- http://pormadi.wordpress.com/2011/11/05/2181/
- Cuma Islam Ritual Buat Apa http://hamdanarfani.blogspot.com/2011/11/cuma-islam-ritual-buat-apa.html

Sejauh ini belum ada yang mempertanyakan keabsahan dari paper tersebut.

Pengukuran keislaman suatu

Pengukuran keislaman suatu negara rupanya bukan barang baru. Ini contohnya: http://www.cordobainitiative.org/2007/10/shariah_project/ . Namun studi ini hasilnya baru jadi tahun 2012

Artikel itu saya dapat link nya dari http://creepingsharia.wordpress.com/2009/07/23/sharia-index-project-will...